True freedom is a living relationship, not rules or manufactured feelings.
- Thad DeBuhr
- Jul 9
- 14 min read
Study Guide: Colossians 2:16-23
Imagine traveling away from home on a long, grueling journey that keeps you separated from your family for months. To get through the lonely nights, you carry a small, creased photo of your spouse in your wallet. You look at it every single day. It reminds you of their face, their smile, and the reality of your love.
But imagine what happens when your journey finally ends. You walk through the front door of your house, and your spouse is standing right there in the living room, arms wide open. What would happen if you completely ignored them, pushed past their hug, sat down on the couch, pulled out your wallet, and just started staring at the little piece of paper instead?
It sounds completely absurd. Yet, this is exactly what happens when we substitute religious rulebooks and manufactured emotional highs for a real, living connection with Jesus. The photo isn't bad—it served a vital purpose. But it was only ever meant to point to the real person. In Colossians 2:16-23, we find a young church struggling to look at the living Savior because they are being pulled back to look at the photos and the shadows instead.
As you go through the study guide, I would suggest reading or listening to the Bible passages in two different bible translations from this list: NIV, NLT, NASB, ESV, NKJV
Learn more about our exciting out-of-the-box ministry here
Setting the Scene
To understand why this letter is so urgent, we have to look at the map and the culture of the ancient world. The town of Colossae was located in Asia Minor, which is modern-day Turkey. Centuries earlier, it had been a massive, bustling center of trade. By the time Paul writes this letter from a distant Roman prison cell, Colossae has shrunk into a much smaller, quiet market town because major Roman roads began to bypass it for neighboring cities.
However, its geographical location in the Lycus Valley meant it was still heavily influenced by a chaotic cultural melting pot where different ideas constantly collided.
Three distinct groups influenced this region, and their ideas were blending into a dangerous religious cocktail:
The Pagan Mystics: The local non-Jewish population was deeply steeped in native folk magic, superstition, and polytheism (the worship of many gods). They believed the air was thick with unseen, hostile spiritual forces, elemental spirits, and planetary rulers that controlled human destiny. To stay safe from these powers, people constantly looked for secret spiritual protections.
The Jewish Community: Generations earlier, a Greek ruler named Antiochus the Great had legally relocated two thousand Jewish families to this immediate region. Because of this, there was a deeply entrenched, traditional Jewish presence throughout the surrounding valley. They brought with them the ancient laws of the Old Testament, including strict dietary restrictions, the Saturday Sabbath, and annual festivals.
The False Teachers: A group of local religious influencers had emerged within the church. They weren't necessarily telling people to abandon Jesus completely. Instead, they were treating Jesus like a basic starter pack. They argued that if you wanted to be an elite, fully protected Christian, you needed an upgrade. They took the strict physical regulations of the Jewish law and supercharged them with the deep, mystical desire for supernatural visions and experiences.
Paul is writing to a church that is feeling immense social and religious pressure. They are being told that their simple, quiet faith in Jesus isn't enough to protect them from the spiritual world or make them right with God.
Walking Through the Passage
In our live reading, we broke down this text into four major movements. Let’s unpack exactly what Paul is saying in these verses, looking closely at the background details a modern reader from the West might easily miss.
1. Shadows vs. The Substance (Colossians 2:16-17)
Paul opens this section with a direct command:
"Therefore do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a New Moon celebration or a Sabbath day." (Colossians 2:16)
Notice the specific list Paul uses here: annual festivals, monthly new moons, and weekly Sabbaths. To a modern Western reader, this just sounds like a random list of religious events. But to anyone from a Jewish background, this specific three-part sequence was instantly recognizable from the Hebrew Scriptures (such as 1 Chronicles 23:31 and Isaiah 1:13-14). It covered the entire religious calendar from the biggest yearly celebrations down to the weekly day of rest.
The false teachers were using these calendar dates as a weapon, telling the Gentile (non-Jewish) believers that they were failing God because they weren't keeping the traditional kosher food laws or observing the Saturday Sabbath.
Paul levels the playing field in verse 17:
"These are a shadow of the things that were to come; the reality, however, is found in Christ."
In the original Greek language, the word for "reality" or "substance" is soma, which literally means "body." Think about how a shadow works. If a person is walking around a street corner, their physical body blocks the sun and casts a long shadow on the ground before they appear. If you are standing there, you can look at the shadow to get an idea of the person's shape and size.
The Old Testament food laws, the sacred sacrifices, and the Sabbath days were a beautiful, God-given shadow. They were designed to sketch out the shape of the coming Messiah.
The Sabbath was a weekly shadow of the permanent spiritual rest Jesus would provide.
The dietary laws were a shadow of the true spiritual purity found in Him.
Paul's point is revolutionary: now that the physical "body" of Jesus has stepped into the room, turning back to the calendar rules is like trying to have a conversation with a shadow on the dirt.
2. Don't Get Disqualified by Fake Elite Groups (Colossians 2:18-19)
Next, Paul tackles the mystical, experiential side of the false teaching:
"Do not let anyone who delights in false humility and the worship of angels disqualify you. Such a person also goes into great detail about what they have seen; they are puffed up with idle notions by their unspiritual mind." (Colossians 2:18)
The Greek word used here for "disqualify" is an athletic term (katabrabeuo). It refers to an umpire or a referee stepping onto the playing field and kicking a runner out of the race, robbing them of their hard-earned prize. The false teachers were acting like self-appointed spiritual umpires, looking at ordinary Christians and saying, "You don't have the prize because you haven't experienced what we have."
What exactly were they experiencing? Paul mentions the "worship of angels" and people going into great detail about things "they have seen" (visions). Scholars note that in the ancient world, particularly in Phrygian mysticism, people would fast and punish their bodies to induce an altered state of mind. They believed they could spiritually ascend into the heavenly realms, slip past the stars, and join the angels in their ecstatic worship of God.
The Modern Copycat (The "Feeling" Trap): This exact same ancient problem is exploding across the modern church in the West today. We see it whenever "Spirit-filled" labels are used to create an elite class of Christians, pastors, or worship services. It is the modern version of the exact same trap: telling you that simply trusting Jesus, walking in quiet obedience, and studying His teaching isn't enough. Instead, you are told you need to feel something intense, experience a "warm and fuzzy" emotional high, or chase a spectacular supernatural sign to be a "real" or mature believer.
The Pressure to Perform: Many feel unwritten pressure to raise hands, speak in tongues, or be hyper-expressive just to prove they are spiritual. Chasing an emotional high in a modern sanctuary copies the ancient false teachers who demanded heavenly visions to stay relevant. People flock to experiential churches because they are addicted to the atmosphere or the emotional release, mistaking a biological goosebump for the presence of the Holy Spirit.
The Root Problem (Disconnected from the Head): Paul completely unmasks this trend. This obsession with elite emotional experiences is driven by a worldly mind, causing people to lose connection with the actual Head of the body—Jesus (Colossians 2:19).
The Body Connection: A physical body only grows when connected to the brain. Trying to "upgrade" your faith through manufactured feelings disconnects you from God, the true source of life and growth. When a human joint pops out of place, it stops receiving signals from the brain and the limb becomes useless. When we chase experiences rather than Christ, we spiritually dislocate ourselves from the only source of real life.
3. Dying to the World's Starter Rules (Colossians 2:20-22)
Paul shifts from an athletic metaphor to a legal and citizen-focused argument:
"Since you died with Christ to the elemental spiritual forces of this world, why, as though you still belonged to the world, do you submit to its rules: 'Do not handle! Do not taste! Do not touch!'?" (Colossians 2:20-21)
Paul uses a bit of heavy sarcasm here. He mimics the frantic, anxious voices of the local religious leaders who were obsessed with contamination. “Don't touch that pagan object! Don't eat that specific meat! Don't handle that item!”
He reminds them of their true identity. In the ancient world, if a slave died, their master could no longer command them, beat them, or enforce the house rules on them. Death broke the legal contract. Paul is saying, "When you were baptized, you died with Christ. You were completely rescued out of the jurisdiction of this broken world system. Why are you still acting like its slave?"
Furthermore, he points out the sheer temporary nature of these physical objects:
"These rules, which have to do with things that are all destined to perish with use, are based on merely human commands and teachings." (Colossians 2:22)
Food is eaten, digested, and gone. Physical objects wear out and break down. Paul is showing how foolish it is to stake your eternal security and spiritual maturity on things that are destined for the trash can anyway.
4. The Illusion of Self-Control (Colossians 2:23)
Paul closes his argument by analyzing why these religious systems are so incredibly popular:
"Such regulations indeed have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-imposed worship, their false humility and their harsh treatment of the body, but they lack any value in restraining sensual indulgence." (Colossians 2:23)
This is one of the most powerful diagnostic verses in the entire New Testament. Paul admits that legalism looks great from the outside. When someone starves themselves, spends hours in rigid prayer routines, punishes their body, and follows a strict moral checklist, they look intensely dedicated. It gives the "appearance of wisdom."
But Paul drops the ultimate hammer: these human rules have absolutely zero value when it comes to actually changing human nature or stopping a person's broken inner desires.
Think of a wild, aggressive dog barking in a backyard. You can build a heavy-duty, ten-foot wooden fence around that dog. The fence is highly effective at controlling the dog's geography—it keeps it from biting the neighbors. But the fence does absolutely nothing to change the dog's nature. On the inside, it is still the exact same wild animal, furiously clawing at the wood to get out.
Human rulebooks and emotional highs are just a geographic fence. They can force you to behave for an hour on Sunday, but they cannot change the fabric of your heart. Only your internal union with Jesus can do that.
Will you partner with us to help more people understand the Bible, grow in community, and follow Jesus?
Learn more about supporting this ministry here.
Why Context Changes Everything
When we study ancient letters like Colossians, it can be very easy to treat them like a dusty history lesson about people who lived two thousand years ago. We read about "angel worship" and "new moon festivals" and think, “Well, I don’t do either of those things, so this passage doesn't apply to me.”
But if we don't understand the core human heart issues driving these ancient problems, we will completely miss the traps waiting for us in our own lives today. We must learn how to read this passage within its original historical and cultural setting so that we can accurately extract the timeless truths Paul is teaching. If we don't, we will end up forcing the Bible to say things it never intended to say.
Applying It Wrong
Here are a few ways modern readers twist, misuse, or misapply Colossians 2:16-23 to fit their own personal or denominational agendas:
The "Throw Away the Old Testament" Trap: Many western Christians read Paul’s words about shadows and Sabbaths and assume he is saying the Old Testament is bad, outdated, or completely useless. They use this passage to justify throwing out the Hebrew Scriptures entirely. This is a massive mistake. Paul isn't disrespecting the Old Testament; he is showing its true glory as the necessary blueprint that successfully pointed the world to Jesus.
The "Anti-Discipline" Excuse: Some people use Paul's warning against human rules as a spiritual green light to live completely lazy, undisciplined lives. They claim that because "rules don't change the heart," any form of spiritual discipline—like consistent Bible study, fasting, or moral boundaries—is legalism. They twist Christian freedom into an excuse for selfish living.
The Denominational Blame Game: People often weaponize verse 23 to attack any church tradition that looks different from their own. High-church traditionalists are accused of "harsh treatment of the body" because of their formal liturgies, while expressive churches are labeled "angel worshippers" because of their emotional style. This misses the point entirely: Paul isn't attacking styles; he is attacking the prideful heart that relies on anything other than Jesus.
Applying It Well
To study this passage with success, keep these contextual anchors in mind:
Look for the Source of Growth: Always ask yourself if a specific practice or teaching is drawing you closer to Jesus (the Head) or if it is drawing attention to the person doing it. Real spiritual growth is organic and flows down from Christ, not upward through human effort.
Distinguish Between Tools and Rules: Spiritual disciplines (like reading your Bible, praying, or fasting) are excellent tools to help you connect with Jesus. But the moment you treat those tools as rules that make you superior to others or earn you extra points with God, you have stepped right into the Colossian trap.
Appreciate the Blueprint: Read the Old Testament through the lens of a house build. You don't hate a blueprint when the actual house is completed; you honor the blueprint by living inside the building it beautifully detailed.
Questions to Chew on and Discuss:
These questions are designed to help you personally dig deeper into the passage and help guide your discussions in your Journey Groups and Me & 3 small groups.
Look Closely
(What does the passage say?)
According to verse 17, what is the specific relationship between the ancient calendar festivals/Sabbaths and Jesus?
What are the specific visual things Paul says the false teachers are doing to pride themselves in verses 18 and 23?
What does Paul say happens to a person's relationship with Jesus (the Head) when they become consumed with chasing elite spiritual experiences?
Dig Deeper
(What did it mean?)
Why does Paul say human regulations like "Do not handle! Do not taste! Do not touch!" are ultimately powerless to change a person's life?
How does the analogy of a shadow and a physical body help us understand the true purpose of the Old Testament laws?
In your own words, explain the difference between a faith built on human rules versus a faith built on a living connection to the "Head."
Let It Sink In
(What is God showing me?)
Have you ever felt the subtle pressure to manufacture an emotional experience or "fake a feeling" during a church service just to look spiritually mature to those around you?
Where in your life do you find yourself slipping back into an anxious checklist lifestyle, secretly hoping that your good behavior will make God love you more?
Does the thought of a quiet, simple, daily obedience to Jesus feel like "enough" to you, or do you constantly feel like you need an extra emotional high to verify your faith?
Live It Out
(What will I do?)
What is one specific religious "checklist item" or performance mindset you need to consciously drop this week to rest in what Jesus has already done?
How can you practically protect your daily schedule this week to ensure you are focusing on a real connection with Jesus, rather than just going through the motions of a religious routine?
Think of a fellow believer who is currently feeling burned out by performance or spiritual anxiety. How can you use the truths in this passage to encourage them over the next few days?
Journey Group OR ME & 3 Small Group Discussion Starters:
Whether you're helping facilitate a small group, talking about this passage one-on-one with a friend, or even just need a topic to guide the conversation at the dinner table, these ideas can help start a good group conversation before you dive into the passage and questions in this study guide.
Discussion Starter Idea:
The Object Lesson: To get your small group talking, bring a framed photograph of someone you love (or a picture on your phone) and set it in the middle of the room. Ask the group: "If I haven't seen this person in years, this photo is incredibly valuable to me. But if they are sitting right next to me on the couch, what happens to the value of this piece of paper? Why do you think we, as Christians, are so deeply tempted to keep staring at the 'paper rules' and emotional 'photos' of faith rather than talking directly to the living Savior who is in the room with us?"
Sum It Up
True spiritual maturity is never found in a rigid human rulebook, nor is it found by frantically chasing a manufactured emotional high. Rules can control your outward geography, and emotions can give you a temporary buzz, but neither has the power to actually transform a broken human heart. Real freedom is found only in a simple, living relationship with Jesus Christ. He is the substance that every shadow pointed to. When you are firmly connected to Him as your Head, you already have everything you need to grow, change, and live fully alive.
Experience the God of the Wilderness
Throughout the Bible, the desert isn't just a place of heat and sand; it is God’s favorite classroom. It’s where He took Moses to see the burning bush, where He shaped the Israelites into a nation, and where Jesus was prepared for His ministry.
There is something about stepping away from the "safe structures" of the city and into the stillness of the high desert that clears the noise and lets you hear God's voice.
Are you willing to come to the wilderness for a time of preparation and growth? If you feel God moving you out of your comfort zone and into a deeper dependence on Him, we invite you to join us on our off-grid property in Northwest Arizona.
Arizona Bible Experience Retreat 📅 Dates: October 17-23, 2026 📍 Location: Meadview, AZ
Incredible scenery, excellent teaching, and friendships forged from slot canyons to campfires. We have limited spots available to keep the experience intimate and impactful.
Several lodging options. Daily excursions. Shared meals, campfires, and more! Includes a day at the West Rim of the Grand Canyon and so much more.
Save the Date: The Pig Out-Play & Praise
Every September, the whole YJJ community rallies together in beautiful North Idaho for our annual gathering. We call it "The Pig Out-Play & Praise"—and for good reason! We smoke a whole hog and briskets for a week of incredible food, deep fellowship, and powerful worship led by two different teams.
The Biblical Connection:
Did you know that God actually built "big meet-ups" into the very rhythm of life for His people? From the Appointed Feasts to the harvest gatherings, the ancient Israelites were commanded to stop, gather, and celebrate what God was doing. The value of these rhythms remains true for us today. We need these "mountain top" moments to refuel and reconnect.
Registration is OPEN now! Get your tickets here:
HAVE YOU WATCHED THIS VIDEO YET?
MORE RESOURCES TO HELP YOU GROW AS A CHRISTIAN
Read Our Full Statement of Faith: CLICK HERE
Your Jesus Journey is an independent, non-denominational Christian ministry. We're fueled by God's grace and the generosity of our supporters. Our team—led by Pastor Thad and his wife Kaila—is made up of dedicated disciples from all over the United States. Together, we work to help people understand the Bible, find Christian friends, and grow as disciple-makers.
Be sure to grab our free E-Book, "Stop Reading the Bible Wrong: 7 Strategic Shifts that Change Everything." Just click the Free Gift button at the top of our website, and we'll send it to you today!
Go to https://www.yourjesusjourney.com/journeygroups to learn more about Journey Groups, get connected in one, or even learn how to start your own. It's like a spiritual potluck, but instead of questionable casseroles, we share insights and grow closer to God. See you there!
You can also get our FREE in-Depth Bible-Study Guides delivered to your inbox: https://forms.wix.com/r/7330608166566101604.
To learn more about YJJ, Thad and Kaila, and Your Jesus Journey, check out our ABOUT US section: https://www.yourjesusjourney.com/learn-about-thad-and-kaila-and-the-journey-church-online.
There's lots more to see and learn on our website, from our "what we believe" page to hundreds of blogs. We encourage you to swing on by and take a look around at www.YourJesusJourney.com!
Thank you